Review Process Guidelines

What points should be considered when assessing the article quality?

1. Is the submitted manuscript clear, correct and within the journal’s scope?

• Are the problems and purposes of the work clearly stated?
• Is the subject of the work within the journal’s scope?
• Is it correct and free of obvious errors?
• Are the mathematics and methodology of the work rigorous?

2. Is the work original and interesting for the readers?

• Is the submitted manuscript original? Does it contain new results that advance the prior research results in its scientific field?
• Has any part of the article already been published elsewhere? Does it constitute plagiarism?
• Is the article scientifically sound and not misleading?
• Is the presentation complete for a scientific article? Is there any critical information missing?

3. Is the presentation of ideas satisfactory?

• Does the title of the article reflect the content of the article?
• Is the abstract well-written to describe the essential information?
• Is the introduction section well-written and satisfactory?
• Is the length of the article appropriate depending on its type?
• Is the conclusion section logically entailed by the results?
• Is the article written in concise and eloquent English?

Tips for writing a review report

Reviewers should consider the following points when writing their review report:

1. There are two sections to write your review, one for the reviewer’s comments to the chief editor and another for the reviewer’s comments to the authors. Your comments to the chief-editor will be read only by the editorial office and will not be revealed to the authors.

2. Provide an overall recommendation for or against the publication of the manuscript to the chief-editor.

3. If you believe that the manuscript requires revision, you are requested to provide constructive comments and suggestions for improving the quality and presentation of the article.

4. When you provide suggestions on revisions, make it clear if they are mandatory or optional.

5. For timely and rapid review, point out all the faults of the article only once. Do not add new criticisms after the authors have submitted the revised version. This will delay the review process and make it endless.

---

Top Reviews of 2020

No.	Reviewer Name	Degree	Position	Country	Affiliation
1	Arasteh, Javad	Ph.D.	Other	Iran	Department of Materials and Metallurgy Engineering, Shahid Dadbin Technical College of Kerman, Kerman, Iran
2	Bastami, Hajieh	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Technical and Vocational University of Tehran, Faculty of Material Science and Engineering, Shariaty College, 18918-16851, Tehran, Tehran, Iran
3	Dadfar, Mohammad Reza	Ph.D.	Other	Iran	Ceramic Department, Materials and Energy Research Center (MERC), Meshkindasht, Alborz, Iran
4	Davarpanah, Leila	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Energy Research Department, Materials and Energy Research Center (MERC), Meshkindasht, Alborz, Iran
5	Delshad Chermahini, Mehdi	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Faculty of Engineering, Shahrekord University, Shahrekord, Chaharmahal and Bakhtiari, Iran
6	Ebadzadeh, Touraj	Ph.D.	Professor	Iran	Research Department of Ceramic, Materials and Energy Research Center (MERC), Meshkin Dasht, Alborz, Iran
7	Elahi, mohammad	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Faculty of Science, Science and Research-Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Tehran, Iran
8	Enayati, Mohammad Hossein	Ph.D.	Professor	Iran	Department of Materials Engineering, Isfahan University of Technology (IUT), Isfahan, 84154-83111,Isfahan, Iran
9	Farvizi, Mohammad	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Research Department of Ceramic, Materials and Energy Research Center (MERC), Meshkin Dasht, Alborz, Iran
10	Ganjali, Monireh	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Nanotechnology and Advanced Materials Department, Material and Energy Research Center (MERC), Alborz, Iran
11	Ghatee, Mojtaba	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Shahrood University of Technology, Shahrood, Semnan, Iran
12	Hayati, Raziye	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Yasouj University, Yasouj, Kohgiluyeh and Boyer-Ahmad, Iran
13	Hosseinifard, Mojtaba	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Department of Semiconductors,  Materials and Energy Research Center (MERC), Meshkindasht, Alborz, Iran
14	Huo, Pengwei	Ph.D.	Professor	China	Institute of Green Chemistry and Chemical Technology, School of Chemistry & Chemical Engineering, Jiangsu University, Zhenjiang 212013, PR China
15	Kalantar, Mahdi	Ph.D.	Associate Professor	Iran	Industrial Metallurgy Group- Mining and Metallurgy Engineering Department- Yazd University, Yazd, Yazd, Iran
16	Kalantarian, Mohammad Mahdi	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Ceramic, Material and Energy Research Center, Meshkindasht, Alborz, Iran
17	Khamseh, Sara	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Department of Nano Materials and Nano Coatings, Institute for Color Science and Technology (ICST), Tehran, Tehran, Iran
18	Khodaei, Mahdi	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Faculty of Materials Science and Engineering K. N. Toosi University of Technology, Tehran, Tehran, Iran
19	Liu, Hui Jun	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	China	Songshan Lake Materials Laboratory, Dongguan, 523808, PR China
20	Mahmoodi, Niyaz Mohammad	Ph.D.	Associate Professor	Iran	Department of Environmental Research, Institute for Color Science and Technology, Tehran, Tehran, Iran
21	Maleki Shahraki, Mohammad	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Department of Materials Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, University of Maragheh, Maragheh, East Azerbaijan, 55181-83111, Iran
22	Manafi, Sahebali	Ph.D.	Professor	Iran	Department of Materials Engineering, Shahrood Branch, Islamic Azad University, Shahrood, Semnan,  Iran
23	Mehdinavaz Aghdam, Rouhollah	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	School of Metallurgy and Materials Engineering, College of Engineering, University of Tehran, Tehran, Tehran, Iran
24	Mobasherpour, Iman	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Department of Ceramic, Materials and Energy Research Center, Meshkindasht, Alborz, Iran
25	Moghanian, Amirhossein	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Materials Engineering, Faculty of Technical & Engineering, Imam Khomeini International University, Qazvin, Iran
26	Mohebbi, Hamed	Ph.D.	Other	Iran	Niroo Research Institute Iran University of Science and Tecnology, Tehran, Tehran, Iran
27	Moradi Alborzi, Morteza	Ph.D.	Associate Professor	Iran	Department of Semiconductors, Materials and Energy Research Center, Meshkindasht, Alborz, Iran
28	Nezafati, Nader	Ph.D.	Associate Professor	Iran	Research Department of Nanotechnology and Advanced Metalls, Materials and Energy Research Center (MERC), Meshkin Dasht, Alborz, Iran
29	Pakseresht, Amir Hossein	Ph.D.	Other	Slovakia	Department of Coatings, Centre for Functional and Surface Functionalized Glass, Alexander Dubček University of Trenčín, Študentská 2, 911 50 Trenčín, Slovakia
30	Pazouki, Mohammad	Ph.D.	Professor	Iran	Research Department of Energy, Materials and Energy Research Center (MERC), Meshkindasht, Alborz, Iran
31	Peng, Biaolin	Ph.D.	Other	China	Research Center for Optoelectronic Materials and Devices, School of Physical Science and Technology, Guangxi University, Nanning 530004, China
32	POURANOURI, MAJID	Ph.D.	Associate Professor	Iran	Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Sharif University of Technology (SUT), Tehran, Tehran, Iran
33	Ramezani, Tayebeh	Ph.D.	Other	Iran	Materials and Energy Research Center (MERC), Meshkindasht, Alborz, Iran
34	Rasteghari Kopaei, Habibollah	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Department of Mechanical and Materials Engineering, Birjand University of Technology, South Khorasan, 97198-66981, Iran
35	Razavi, Mansour	Ph.D.	Associate Professor	Iran	Research Department of Ceramic, Materials and Energy Research Center (MERC), Meshkin Dasht, Alborz, Iran
36	Rezvani, Mohammad	Ph.D.	Professor	Iran	Department of Materials Science and Ceramics, University of Tabriz, Tabriz, East Azerbaijan, Iran
37	Sabet, Hamed	Ph.D.	Associate Professor	Iran	Department of Metallurgy and Materials Engineering Karaj Branch, Islamic Azad University Karaj, Alborz, Iran
38	Saghafian Larijani, Hassan	Ph.D.	Associate Professor	Iran	School of Metallurgy and Materials Engineering, Iran University of Science and Technology, Narmak, Tehran, 16846-13114, Tehran, Iran
39	Salahinejad, Erfan	Ph.D.	Associate Professor	Iran	Department of materials science and engineering, Khajeh Nasir Toosi University, Tehran, Tehran, Iran
40	Salavati-Niasar, Masoud	Ph.D.	Professor	Iran	Institute of Nano Science and Nano Technology, University of Kashan, Kashan, P.O. Box 87317-51167, Isfahan, Iran
41	Salehi, Samira	Ph.D.	Other	Iran	Department of Energy, Niroo Research Institute (NRI), Tehran, Tehran, Iran
42	Salimi, Esmaeil	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Department of materials science and engineering, Shahrood University of Technology, Shahrood, Semnan,  Iran
43	Sayyedan, Fatemehsadat	Ph.D.	Other	Iran	Department of Materials Engineering Isfahan University of Technology, Isfahan 8415683111, Isfahan, Iran
44	Sedaghat Ahangari Hossein Zadeh, Ali	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Ceramic Research Department, Materials and Energy Research Center, Meshkin Dasht, Alborz, Iran
45	Shidpour, Reza	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Materials Engineering Department, Babol Noshirvani University of Technology, Babol, Mazandaran, Iran
46	Shojaie, Maryam	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Faculty of Chemical Engineering and material, Shahrood University of Technology, shahrood, Semnan, Iran
47	Shokrvash, Hussein	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Department of Materials Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, University of Maragheh, PO Box 55181-83111, Maragheh, East Azerbaijan, Iran
48	Sun, Wenhong	Ph.D.	Other	China	Research Center for Optoelectronic Materials and Devices, School of Physical Science and Technology, Guangxi University, Nanning 530004, China & Guangxi Key Laboratory of Processing for Non-ferrous Metal and Featured Materials, China
49	Țălu, Ștefan	Ph.D.	Associate Professor	Romania	The Directorate of Research, Development and Innovation Management (DMCDI), Constantin Daicoviciu Street, no. 15, Cluj-Napoca, 400020, Cluj county, Romania
50	Tayebifard, seyed ali	Ph.D.	Associate Professor	Iran	Semiconductors Department, Materials and Energy Research Center, Meshkin Dasht, Alborz, Iran
51	Torknik, Fatemeh Sadat	Ph.D.	Other	Iran	Semiconductors Research Department, Materials and Energy Research Center (MERC), Meshkindasht, Alborz, Iran
52	Yaghobizadeh, Omid	Ph.D.	Assistant Professor	Iran	Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Faculty of Technology and Engineering, Imam Khomeini International University, Qazvin 3414896818, Qazvin, Iran
53	Zakeri, Mohammad	Ph.D.	Associate Professor	Iran	Ceramics Department, Materials and Energy Research Center, Meshkindasht, Alborz, Iran

 

 All Reviews List